|
Jiang Zemin poses a unique challenge to
international rule of law because he has hidden his crimes behind
the veil of the Chinese Government and a formidable information
blockade. |
|
|
COMMENTARY -- Dec. 19, 2003 Falun Dafa Information Center,
www.faluninfo.net
NEW YORK -- It's been a tough few weeks for former dictators,
and you can be sure China's former leader, Jiang Zemin, has been paying
attention.
On December 4th, European media reported that the
Nuremberg District Court in Germany issued an arrest warrant for former
Argentine President, Jorge Videla, for the alleged torture and killing of
thousands during Videla's rule in the late 1970's and early 1980's. This past
week, former NATO allied commander, Wesley Clark, testified that Slobodan
Milosevic had prior knowledge of a massacre in Srebrenica that eventually left
over 7,000 dead, thereby strengthening the genocide case against the former
Yugoslavian leader. And last weekend, former Iraqi dictator, Saddam Hussein, was
found hiding in a hole, bearded and weary from months on the run.
All the while, a recently published book on how to oust the
world's last remaining dictators by 2025 written by former U.S. Ambassador and
26-year veteran of the U.S. State Department, Mr. Mark Palmer, continues to
garner rave reviews by columnists across North America.
A December 16th Wall Street Journal piece
called Mr. Palmer's book, "One of the best but least noticed books among all the
tomes addressing the quest for peace in the post-Sept. 11 era."
The book, "Breaking the Real Axis of Evil," is a blueprint
foreign policy manual on how to rid the world of the last remaining dictators: A
collection of 45 leaders Mr. Palmer calls "the world's 45 least wanted."
Indeed, the world is a very different place for dictators
than it was almost sixty years ago when the United Nations began to adopt
landmark treaties to address the horrific crimes that all-too-often are bred in
their shadows. The U.N. Convention on Genocide was adopted in 1948 and the U.N.
Convention on Torture in 1984, just to name a few.
Since that time, such treaties and the laws they spawned have
had some success in bringing to justice those who perpetuate crimes against
humanity. Indeed, international rule of law has extended its reach into circles
of sovereign power where, until recently, dictators' domestic power reigned
absolutely. Just ask Chile's Augusto Pinochet or Liberia's Charles Taylor.
International Law's Unique Challenge
Yet, as the intolerance for dictators reaches unprecedented
heights, the laws and treaties enshrined by the international community to
protect against severe human rights violations face perhaps their most unique
challenge in the likes of China's former leader, Jiang Zemin.
In July 1999, Jiang launched a violent campaign against Falun
Gong characterized by CNN's Senior China Analyst, Willy Lam, as a "throw-back to
the Cultural Revolution." For those familiar with modern Chinese history, the
comparison conjures up terrifying images of arbitrary imprisonment, wanton
beatings and torture, and thousands killed amidst the mayhem.
According to the Falun Dafa Information Center, details of
842 deaths (reports
/
sources) have been verified, with informed sources putting the true death
toll well in the thousands.
Hundreds of thousands have been detained, with more than
100,000 being sentenced to forced labor camps, typically without trial,
according to the Center.
Topping Amnesty International's list of human rights
"scoundrels," clearly Jiang's crimes place him along side Hussein, Milosevic,
Pinochet and other "least wanted." Yet, with so much evidence stacked against
him, why does Jiang still present a challenge to international rule of law whose
statutes are so clear on these issues? The answer is three-fold.
A Personal Decision Disguised as Government Policy
First, Jiang has made himself a difficult target to pinpoint
by thoroughly blurring the lines between his personal will and the policies of
the Chinese Government. To this day, many of the world's population believe the
"Falun Gong issue" to be a struggle between the Chinese Government and Falun
Gong. This perception is no accident, but the result of carefully calculated
steps taken by Jiang to utilize the government apparatus for his own purpose.
Jiang not only formulated the policy of "eradicating" Falun
Gong himself, but actually went against the decision of the Premier and the
entire Politburo Standing Committee -- who were advocating for Falun Gong in
1999 -- to enact the persecutory campaign against Falun Gong. (in-depth
/
special report) Thus, as the nation's top leader who also headed the
military, Jiang commandeered the government apparatus to carry out the
persecution, while at the same time creating the impression it was a
government-backed initiative from the beginning.
As Mr. Palmer recently told the media during an interview
about his new book, "Jiang Zemin individually made this decision ... [he] went
against many other people in his own politburo who did not want to do this to
the Falun Gong, some of whom even practiced the Falun Gong or had relatives who
practiced the Falun Gong. So we need to hold him accountable."
A New Form of Genocide?
Secondly, the full-scale of the crimes that constitute the
persecution of Falun Gong are diverse, hard to classify in a single category and
difficult to verify in a state that dedicates significant national resources to
stem the flow of such information. True, there are over thirty thousand
documented cases of arbitrary arrest, torture, killings and other known forms of
severe human rights violations against Falun Gong practitioners. But the
systematic nature of exactly what is happening in China to Falun Gong
practitioners -- something more akin to genocide than religious suppression --
remains an unclear picture in the mind's eye of the international community.
Throughout the tumultuous reign of the Communist Party in
China, complex, diverse and often violent methods of persecution were developed
and refined. These methods aimed to completely isolate a segment of society and
extinguish it by "transforming" individuals' hearts and minds to be in line with
the Party, by any means necessary. In this "transformation" process, thousands
lose their lives amidst the violent methods employed, but ultimately the goal of
such persecution is not simply to kill the targeted group of people outright --
the traditional concept of genocide. The goal is to strip them of their beliefs.
This eradication of belief attacks the core of what it means to be human.
Consider, for example, what would have happened in World War
II if Hitler's Nazis had -- rather than sending 6 million Jewish people to their
deaths -- instead sought to strip them of their beliefs by sending them to
brainwashing centers. At the brainwashing centers, they would be subjected to
torture and a barrage of brainwashing techniques that ravaged them to the point
where they renounce Judaism, publicly condemn Moses, willingly burn the Torah
and cooperate with Nazi officials to help "transform" other Jews, or face being
killed in the process if they remain steadfast.
Is this genocide or is it something else we don't quite have
a name for? Regardless, this is the form of persecution that was unleashed upon
Falun Gong in 1999, and it is a horrific crime against humanity.
Media Blitz
The third reason Jiang may present a challenge to
international law is that throughout the campaign against Falun Gong, Jiang has
employed the tried-and-true method of exercising "the pen and the sword" in
unison. During the 1999 APEC meeting in New Zealand, Jiang met with Bill
Clinton. According to the Associated Press, Jiang handed Clinton a book
assembled by Chinese propagandists that vilified Falun Gong, and no-doubt asked
the then-U.S. President to toe the line. Similar materials demonizing Falun Gong
have been delivered to governments and media around the world in an attempt to
paint Falun Gong as "dangerous" or a menace to society, claims that human rights
organizations such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch call,
"Unproven," "Bogus" and part of a "Massive Propaganda Campaign."
Still, if you repeat a lie enough times, people begin to
believe it. Today, information from Jiang's anti-Falun Gong materials has spread
throughout the world. To the casual observer, fact and fiction have become
intertwined. Indeed, bits of Jiang's misinformation can even be found in Western
media reports and academic studies.
Clearly, most China-watchers know the regime is spreading
lies about Falun Gong, but when done so thoroughly and on such a large scale,
the lies still have the effect of encouraging people to turn the other way.
"Never Again"
Jiang poses a test for international rule of law because he
has hidden himself well behind the Chinese Government, the full scale of his
crimes are difficult to classify and uncover, and his worldwide campaign of
misinformation about Falun Gong has dimmed the enthusiasm of would-be critics.
Indeed, Jiang is a magician of sorts, and the world remains a
bit mesmerized. But this is no magic show. It's torture. It's genocide against a
traditional, peaceful belief. It's everything for which we promised ourselves
"never again" as the horrors of Auschwitz and Buchenwald were laid bare before
our eyes.
# # #
COMMENTARY -- Dec. 19, 2003
Falun Dafa Information Center,
www.faluninfo.net
Background
Falun Gong, also known as Falun Dafa (about),
is a practice of meditation and exercises with teachings based on the universal
principle of "Truthfulness-Compassion-Tolerance." Practiced in over
50
countries world-wide, Falun Gong has roots in traditional Chinese culture.
With government estimates of as many as
100
million practicing Falun Gong in China, China's then-Communist leader, Jiang
Zemin, outlawed the peaceful practice in July 1999 (report).
Since that time, Jiang's regime has intensified its propaganda campaign to turn
public opinion against the practice while imprisoning, torturing and even
murdering those who practice it. The Falun Dafa Information Center has verified
details of 842 deaths (reports
/
sources) since the persecution of Falun Gong in China began in 1999. In
October 2001, however, Government officials inside China reported that the
actual death toll was well over 1,600. Expert sources now estimate that figure
to be much higher.
Hundreds of thousands have been detained, with more than
100,000 being sentenced to forced labor camps, typically without trial.
FOR MORE INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT THE FALUN DAFA
INFORMATION CENTER -- Gail Rachlin 917-501-4441, Levi Browde 914-720-0963,
Erping Zhang 646-533-6147, or Christina Chai 917-386-5068. Email:
contact@faluninfo.net, Website:
http://www.faluninfo.net/
